It was not temporary.
My mother, I would learn many years later, had studied architecture for one year at the community college before she got pregnant with Jolene at 19. She dropped out, married my father, and never drew another building again.
But I did not know that yet. All I knew was that my sister got a new dress and I got a label.
The label worked like a sorting system. Once it was in place, everything else organized itself around it.
School photos. Every fall, the order forms came home. My mother ordered a full portrait package for Jolene. An 8×10 glossy, framed for the living room wall. For me, she checked the box for wallet size.
$2.50.
The prints went into a kitchen drawer with expired coupons and dead batteries.
Birthdays. Jolene got theme parties. Princess party at seven. Spa party at 10. Pool party at 12 with a DJ.
My birthday was three weeks after my brother Caleb’s. Every year, my mother combined them.
“It just makes sense,” she said.
The cake always said, “Happy birthday, Caleb,” with my name squeezed underneath in smaller frosting letters, like an afterthought someone had caught at the last minute.
Christmas morning. Jolene opened boxes of carefully chosen outfits, coordinated sets, shoes that matched, a coat with a faux fur collar the year she turned 14.
I got books.
“You like reading, right?” my mother would say, not as a question, but as an instruction. Here is what you are. Here is what you get.
My brother Caleb played his part, too. The smart one. He accepted his label and ran with it straight out of the house at 17. Early admission to a state school 400 miles away.
He was neither cruel to me nor kind. He was absent. And absence, I learned, is its own form of agreement.
A label is not a word. It is a permission slip. It tells everyone around you exactly how much space you are allowed to take up, how much attention you deserve, how much effort you are worth.
My family wrote that permission slip when I was six, and every year after that, they renewed it.
If you want to know how a family really sees you, count the photographs.
Our living room had 14 framed photos on the wall. My mother arranged them herself, gallery style, centered above the sofa.
Jolene appeared in all 14. My brother appeared in six. I appeared in three.
In the first one, I was partially hidden behind a cousin at a Fourth of July picnic. In the second, my face was half cut by the frame’s edge, like whoever mounted it did not notice me sliding out of view.
In the third, I was five, squinting into the sun, holding a balloon. That one stayed up because the balloon was red and matched the sofa cushions.
The arrangement was not accidental.
Every family photo session, my mother directed us like a set designer. Jolene front and center. Caleb left side.
“Faith, move back a little.”
And I did every time. One step back, two steps back, until I was furniture.
At Jolene’s high school graduation, my mother took 47 photos. I know because I saw the camera roll when she left her phone on the kitchen counter.


